|
Post by soil3 on May 22, 2007 12:17:00 GMT -5
Korrosiv, I had his stats for the 1st game since he quitted. We finished the game and I gave the stats to him to add up the stats for his team to make it seem reasonable and not odd. I'd like to see if you could give him some kind of suspension for his action in the first half of the game. Since I did my part on writng both stats down for the game, there should be a discipline action for his qutting which is against the rules....
** One quit game is removal from the league
**If an owner pulls the plug one time in the season, they’ll be removed
** If an owner obviously has connection problems week in and week out, you’ll be asked to give your team up. There is no set # to get kicked out, we go according to disconnects, and how often they occur
|
|
|
Post by patron55 on May 22, 2007 13:08:47 GMT -5
ok like i sed b4 i didnt quit y should i get punished for a connection problem. i would have gladly finished the game but after u picked ur play i picked my play and it went to the feild and it sed the connection to your oppenent has been lost. This is the 1st time i have gotten d/c but its something that happens randomly i have no control over it. soo please consider b4 handing out a suspension. i already have accepted my penalty for forgetting to use qb vision. but this is unreasonable because i didnt quit.
|
|
|
Post by korrosivd on May 22, 2007 15:35:33 GMT -5
First of all, I am getting very tired of people making suggestions on when to impose penalties or suspensions, or how to enforce the rules of this league. I dont need people to quote rules for me as I understand them. I am and have been very diplomatic in my approaches, and my reputation will stand so far. I can only advise you that unfortunately if you disagree with the decisions, you may leave, or suck it up and play on. It's a game, and there is no money on the line here, pride yes, money, no.
Conclusion:
There will be no suspension for discconnecting accidentally during this game. I cannot suspend someone for a technology problem and since he was winning at the time, I need to give him the benefit of the doubt here in that why would he quit this game. I cannot call someone a liar, nor will I. The Saints guy contacted me during the game and told me he just got disconn'd and what should he do. The fact that Soil had the stats means Saints did not jiggle (pull the plug) or force a disconn of the game (which can be done). I need to be fair as I have not found Saints to be a lying owner.
I have surveyed teams that have played Saints (2) and both have told me that he is a true sim player and never broke any rules during their games. This season I have had 2 issues with Saints owner, the first being an issue in his first game and 2nd being an admitted mistake. I will not go crazy here but I will place Saints owner on probation whereby if he is to receive any more rules violations, JDidd and I will discuss expulsion from the league and at least major player suspensions.
The Colts owner has had one suspension for padding stats and unsim play. The Colts owner knowingly broke a rule in the game vs Saints in that he accepted a Roughing the Kicker penalty. I will not issue a suspension, although it merits a small one.
As Commish, under the entire circumstances i cannot issue suspensions for this game but note as I have noted above.
I think both players need to tone it down a little with the aggravated responses to one another and perhaps look at this game as a beginining of a wonderful challenge and rivalry opportunity here. I know these games can get heated and many of us really hate to lose.
Unfortunately this league is quite young and we have not widdled out owners who will survive well into the 08 Madden seasons next year. I cannt be rash with decisions, so please try to understand.
BTW, I dont personally know either of these players.
KorrosivD
|
|